I mentioned recently that I’ve been using a Field Notes memo book, so today I thought I’d review it. I’m afraid I’m not a huge fan of these notebooks, as you’ll see below. I had high hopes for them, having seen them around the internet, but I’m very disappointed with the paper quality.
I love the appearance and size of the memo book. It’s a perfect pocket size (intentionally!) and I love the rounded corners. On the front cover it says “Field Notes” in black capital letters, which I like. Underneath the title, it says “48-Page Memo Book Durable Materials / Made in the U.S.A”. I’d like to know what “durable materials” they think it is made with. From my assessment of the notebook, it’s made with thin card, thin paper and three staples. Those aren’t what I would consider “durable materials”. Remember when I took the mick out of Moleskine for pretending their notebooks would be good in Antarctica? At least their notebooks won’t immediately disintegrate if they get wet. Last time I checked, that’s what happened to thin cardboard.
MOVING ON, the back cover has discrete version of the Field Notes logo again, and a web link, and some blurb about being printed in the U.S.A.
The inside front cover has a lovely ‘start’ page, with a section for your name, “pertinent co-ordinates”, a start and finish date and a box for contact details. I love this page! I basically want a durable notebook that has this page in the inside cover.
The back inside cover has the Field Notes story, a list of uses for the notebook (suggestion #6: Half-Ass Calculations), the notebooks specifications and contact details for the company. The specifications printed are possibly some of the most detailed I’ve see from a notebook company. It details where the notebooks are made, what materials they’re made with, the machines they made with and more.
Now we get on to the paper test, which is where this notebook falls apart, in my opinion (not literally). It’s not the quality of paper I expected. It’s a smooth paper, and is a clean white colour (none of my close up photos show the colour accurately), but it’s very thin. It’s like copy paper.
My fine Lamy nib feathers slightly, bleeds and shows through the page. I use this ink/nib combination in most notebook reviews so I now it’s not the pen’s fault.
Ballpoint pens show through the paper, and cause indentation.
I think really the only writing instrument you could enjoy using with these notebooks is a pencil – which incidentally is what field notes used to be written with, so maybe that was the manufacturer’s intention.
If I was given the opportunity to re-design these notebooks, these are the changes I would make:
- A cover made of heavier card stock
- 90g paper
The rest I would keep the same!
I think this is my most “disappointed” notebook review ever. Have you tried Field Notes? What did you think?
I will be doing a giveaway of a Field Notes memo book tomorrow, so come back if you’d like to win one (or come back anyway!).